Numerous times in the past I’ve talked about the importance of good loot design when it comes to ARPG or RPG game design. Because loot is tied to progression it is vital that the developer gets it right in order to keep someone invested in playing. For today’s post I want to look at two very different games and how they both have opposite problems when it comes to loot design.

Diablo 3 560x200 Guns vs. Swords    Borderlands vs. Diablo 3 Loot Design

Diablo 3:

Before we talk more in detail, here is a primer on both games for those who haven’t played them. In Diablo 3, loot generation is randomly generated based on a linear foundation of loot tables. The higher your level, the better the loot table you’ll get items from. This also means that all loot and enemy stats are constantly scaling and keeping pace with your level.

The primary attribute of your character will determine the viability of any loot that you find along with special affixes that give them unique properties. Getting higher tier loot is done by killing elite enemies, bosses and completing rifts, with crafting as a side.

Loot generation or variety is based on the following properties:

  • The equipment type (11 possible categories)
  • The rarity (6 possible varieties)
  • Weapon stats (attack speed, damage)
  • Affixes (All possible affixes plus the four key attributes)

Borderlands:

The Borderlands series has always been about having a lot of guns to choose from. Beyond just the weapon types, the game’s fictional manufacturers also change the properties of the guns and have unique affixes to it.

Similar to Diablo 3, equipment comes in rarity tiers which determine additional affixes or boosted attributes. Getting rare weapons is a bit harder as enemies will drop basic gear with a slightly higher chance from elite enemies. Regular and special chests hidden around the world are the best chances at getting rare goods.

Because of how much the weapon stats have to be taken into account due to the player’s skill being part of the game, it makes attribute generation very important. Here is the number of factors when it comes to a Borderland’s gun:

  • Type of gear (gun, shield, grenade, class mod, oz kit for the presequel)
  • Manufacturer (7 possible)
  • Attributes (custom to each type of gear along with type of gun)
  • Rarity tier (5)

You may notice that both games have the same number of attributes, but the thing to realize is that are a lot more variables category for Borderlands than there are for Diablo 3. In Borderlands, each type of gear has its own unique set of attributes which are generated at loot creation which are also based on a scale.

The problem with loot generation between these two titles is how each game’s philosophy makes it harder to progress in terms of loot.

Differing Loot Table:

With Diablo 3 is that the designers made the loot tables very rigid in an attempt to control progression. This means the chance of finding upgrades is very small due to the limited scales of attributes. As you’re playing through and leveling up, the loot table that determines the gear you find also grows. However it only grows after every few levels so that there is a big difference between level 4 gear and level 8 gear.

Borderlands presequel 6 300x240 Guns vs. Swords    Borderlands vs. Diablo 3 Loot Design

The loot in Borderlands is so diverse that it’s hard to find the items you want or upgrades.

But what happens is that once you find one really good piece of gear, it becomes harder to find something to replace it until you reach the next loot table.

And once you hit the level cap and only have one loot table, finding better gear becomes very annoying as you need to find something that has the affixes you want and have them scaled higher than your current gear.

In this way Diablo 3’s loot design is so rigid that finding better gear becomes harder and harder. But Borderlands 2 has a different problem.

The loot generation in Borderlands is all about variety thanks to the different gun types, rarity and manufacturers. You’re going to find a ton of weapons while you play, but the problem is finding guns that you can use. I can’t tell you the number of times that opening chests gave me nothing or killing bad-ass (Borderland’s elite enemies) had nothing of use.

This makes the difficulty swing between not finding anything and being unprepared, or finding that one weapon that carries you for a long time. To put it another way, Diablo 3’s problem is that good loot is trying to find a needle in a hay stack, while Borderland’s problem is trying to find a specific piece of hay in a hay stack.

Possible Solutions:

The big question is what can be done to move these two series away from their respective loot problems. For Diablo 3, I think there needs to be a few more loot tables similar to what they did at launch to give players at max level a chance at finding better loot that isn’t so rigid. As it stands, the end game is dependent on finding legendary or set items for improvement, but their drop rate is so low combined with finding something that has the stats you need.

skysplitter 300x193 Guns vs. Swords    Borderlands vs. Diablo 3 Loot Design

While in Diablo 3, the range of loot that you can actually use and upgrade from is very narrow.

With Borderlands, there either needs to be more chests or go the Diablo route and give enemies a chance at dropping rare loot.

The grinder introduced in the Presequel that lets you take weapons you don’t use and destroy them for something better was a good start and giving more control to loot finding. But again, with all the variables available at loot generation, still makes it too out of control.

Hack and Shooting:

Loot table design is one of the trickiest aspects when coming up with RPG systems and problems arise when there is too much or not enough loot to go around. Both games have fully committed to their systems and only time will tell with how the developers will improve things.

Tagged with: , , ,

Posted By

THOUGHTS ON
“Guns vs. Swords — Borderlands vs. Diablo 3 Loot Design”

  • Charles Geringer

    I think this article is a bit too
    simplistic. For starters, Borderlands (BL1) and Borderlands 2 (BL2) have very different
    loot-generation systems.

    In BL1 a designer cannot set the chance of a weapon
    dropping, rather when the weapon generated each part has it´s own separate
    “loot roll” and then is combined for the final weapon. Moreover the weapon is
    rolled when the enemy is generated and they actually drop the weapon they are
    using in BL2 a designer can program a boss to drop X weapons of tier Y.

    This has some very far reaching consequences.

    In BL1 the power level variation
    is a lot greater and much more random than in either Diablo or BL2 and since
    this variation carries over to the enemies it also made the enemies more varied
    than Diablo in which enemies of the same type do not have different equipment.
    It also means that if a given weapon got good loot rolls in all or most of it´s
    parts, it will remain viable for a long while, and if the weapons dropped by a
    boss all get bad rolls for it´s parts, the boss can drop weak weapons that are
    useless to the player.

    In the article you said: “With
    Borderlands, there either needs to be more chests or go the Diablo route and
    give enemies a chance at dropping rare loot.” And this happened in BL1: enemies sometimes
    dropped awesome loot, unfortunately bosses sometimes also dropped lackluster
    loot.

    Since the weapon´s effectiveness
    will also be affected by the character’s skill with that weapon´s type and the
    level difference between him and the enemy (BL character’s get bonus damage against
    lower level enemies, and cause less damage against higher level enemies). If a
    player gets a good weapon at the beginning of the game and grinds enough to be
    a few levels above what the designers predicted he can keep a favorite weapon
    viable for a long time.

    Another important point is that
    BL

    It is important to note that in
    borderlands the player carries and frequently changes trough 4 weapons, so
    having on weapon be permanently assigned to one slot isn´t that harmfull to the
    loot treadmill since one can still progress in the other slots. This is still
    true to an extent in Diablo, since there are many equipment slots (Helmet,
    boots, etc..) but not as much as in BL
    due to the next point:

    The way
    the player interacts with items in general and weapons in particular in borderlands
    is completely different and a lot less abstracted from the way he interacts
    with the weapons in Diablo which means that in the borderlands series, all the
    attributes of the weapons have a much greater impact in the moment-to-moment
    gameplay:

    A weapon with a greater attack rate in Diablo
    does affect strategy, but in a micro scale the way you use it is still just
    clicking in the enemy and letting your character do the same repetitive action
    (“clickfest”).

    In borderlands
    the fire rate makes a lot of difference in the moment to moment gameplay, if
    your weapon has a low rate of fire it is a lot more important to aim carefully,
    if it has a high rate of fire one can spray bullets as viable strategy. This comparison
    can be extended to most of the attributes of weapon design in Diablo and BL.

    Another
    point is that the guns in borderlands have a lot more personality than in Diablo.
    If when I am playing in Diablo using a sword and I find a sword that is about
    as good as the one about using, it isn´t really a choice, However if I am
    playing borderlands and find a shotgun that is is about as good as the one I am
    using but FEELS different, it can be a real choice, even though it won´t affect
    my effectiveness from a numbers standpoint it will affect my moment-to-moment
    gameplay and my enjoyment of the game.

Return to Top ▲Return to Top ▲